LAW
Alarming Trends: From Forced Marriages to Honor Based Violence
16 October, 2014
Alarming Trends: From Forced Marriages to Honor Based Violence
Are women’s rights protected in Georgia? Unfortunately, the answer to this question is “No.” Regardless of ethnicity, women’s rights are frequently subject to violation. In some cases, women aren’t recognized as people at all. Such a harsh conclusion is founded on rather depressing statistics, which document numerous cases of wives murdered by their husbands or relatives over the course of just a single year.

Recently, in Kakheti’s village of Lambalo, relatives of 30-year-old Khanum Jeiranova found her hanged, an apparent suicide She did not have any psychological problems that could have pushed her towards suicide; her husband’s relatives drove her to it. Shortly before the tragic act, they severely beat Khanum in public, humiliating her before the entire village. The attackers had seen Khanum together with an unknown man and considered this sufficient for accusing her of adultery. Nobody asked her who this man was and what the nature of their interaction was. Apparently, the ethnic minority-populated enclave where Khanum lived considers it pointless to ask a woman (especially a married woman) anything because she is not allowed an opinion to begin with. Otherwise it is unexplainable why no one attempted to intervene and prevent a woman from getting beaten in the center of the village. Despite the fact that the woman was abused in front of them for hours, no one objected and no one called the police to end the dreadful scene. Nobody called the ambulance, either. Nothing happened to sober up the people among which many Khanums, Azizas and others suffer from lack of rights.
The only person who was somehow sentimental to Khanum’s tragedy, was her own husband himself, the very man who according local customs, had to kill or banish her in first place, “for being unfaithful”.

AJI HASANOV, Khanum Jeiranova’s husband: – “We lived together for 14 years. We worked together. She always helped me. When this happened I was shepherding the sheep. My cousins caught her in somebody’s car. That boy was from Kazlar. At first they beat Khanum on the spot; then they took her by car to the center and publicly beat her there. From the center she walked home bare-footed.
Khanum was an honest person. Before committing suicide she requested to see her children but they were with my brother… They keep asking me where their mother is. For me, life has no meaning. I have neither a mother, nor a father. My
wife hung herself because of shame. I’ll sell all my cattle and leave this place. My wife didn’t deserve all this.”

– What would you do if you found out that your wife betrayed you?

– “I wouldn’t kill her but I’d force her out of the house. She was 16 years old when I kidnapped her. For 14 years we lived a happy life together but this is how our life has ended” – says Khanum’s husband in an interview with Kviris Palitra.

The case is currently being investigated by the police on grounds of driving a person to suicide.

LIMONA ALAZOVA, resident of yet another minority-dominated village, Keshelo, is also 30 years old, same age as Khanum. She is alive, but fears for her life.
Due to injuries to her torso and head that she suffered at the hands of her cousins a few days ago, Limona ended up in intensive care. Just like Khanum, she was accused of adultery. Her cousins beat her senseless and then shot her twice.
According to Limona, members of her family accused her of having sexual relations with another man and promised to kill her for that. Now she doesn’t want to leave the hospital, saying that a terrible fate awaits her at home at the hands of her family. Moreover, even neighbors have turned against Limona, promising to exile her from the village. And the reason for this entire tragedy is some man who parked his car in front of Limona Alazova’s house. The woman has been divorced for ten years, but her neighbors insist that the likes of her aren’t only forbidden to approach other men, but are considered adulterers even if someone stops a car near their homes.
The victim has already told the police what happened to her. According to the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the investigation into the case is already ongoing.
Almost simultaneously with Limona’s and Khanum’s tragedies, 21-year-old Ulfukar Guliev was murdered in the Azerbaijani-majority village of Kazlar, Sagarejo region. The youth was killed for his infatuation with a certain girl and a desire to marry her. The death sentence was allegedly carried out by the girl’s family.
Law enforcement officers have already apprehended 42-year-old Novruz Q., the girl’s father, on charges of premeditated murder. Novruz’s wife and two sons, also suspects in this sadistic murder, are currently in hiding. According to the claims of Ulfukar’s relatives, the youth and the 15-year-old girl loved each other, but the girl’s family did not like her choice and declared that she has no say in this matter and that they will arrange her marriage with the person they deem worthy. They claim that the girl informed her beloved of her parents’ intentions and they decided to elope. However, the car in which they attempted their escape failed to start. By one account, upon exiting the car, Ulpukar suffered a heavy hit on the head with the back of an axe that the girl’s enraged father wielded. Unconscious, he was dragged out into the house’s yard, where he was bound with a rope and tortured to death with sticks, a metal rod and cigarettes. The torture lasted for several hours, and the body of the youth bore numerous burns to face and lips.
Relatives of the victim threaten the family with lynching if the police fail to bring them to justice. On the other side, 15 year old Nargiz Karimova, Ulfukar’s supposed love interest, says he didn’t love the boy and wasn’t asking to be kidnapped, as it is told by Ulfukar’s relatives:
“I didn’t know Ulfukar at all. As it turned out he saw me at a wedding and liked me. His mother came several times to ask for my hand but my family refused because I’m under-age, only 15 years old…”

– Could you tell us what happened that day?

– “It was 2 o’clock a.m. My brothers slept in the same room. Two boys snuck in, covered my mouth with a hand and warned me not to utter a sound and took me out. A car was parked at the house and they put me in it. My father heard some noise and rushed out. My brothers also came out and took me inside the house. I don’t know what happened afterwards. There was no light at home and I could see nothing.”

– They say that you sent Ulfukar an SMS asking him to come because your father wanted you to marry somebody else. Weren’t you waiting for the car at your house?

– “No, I have no telephone. If I wanted to be his wife I would go away secretly in the daytime, neither my father, nor my brothers would know about it. I didn’t love him. I didn’t want him to be killed, but if I loved him, I would ask my father to give me to him…” – said the girl in an interview with Kviris Palitra.
Yet there are people in this village who justify the murderers’ actions. According to them, Ulfukar Guliev crept into the girl’s bedroom at night to kidnap her, bringing dishonor to her family and thus, apparently, becoming “fair game.” Such statements are hard to believe, but the sad reality is that they still exist, even in the 21st century. Even sadder is the fact that many underage girls are still married out this way, without anyone asking their opinion regarding their grooms.
Just recently, a photo published on Facebook by the “Anti-Violence Network of Georgia” caused an outrage. According to the description, the photo depicts a 17-year-old girl in one of Kakheti’s villages, who supposedly is being forcefully married. The underage bride is in tears at the prospect of leaving her home. It says that the first time she saw her future husband was the day of her wedding.
It is unlikely that this girl, like 15-year-old Nargiz, will ever be able to shape her own future due to the strict and cruel influence of the household they were raised in. It is highly unlikely that they and many other girls will ever know about the 11th of October, which is the International Day of the Girl Child.
The purpose of this day is to raise awareness in society about gender inequality-related issues. It is proclaimed in the UN resolution 66/170 that support of girls’ rights is necessary to protect them from violence and discrimination and to allow them to feel that they have a future. The first and main targets of this cause are the governments that turned a blind eye when the likes of Khanum Jeiranova and Limona Alazova were abused and tortured, or when husbands murdered their wives in front of their own little children.
The Georgian office of UN Women has been researching gender inequality-related issues and cases of violence against women since 2010. They believe that the current situation will change only if public awareness of the issue is increased.

TAMAR SABEDASHVILI, program specialist of UN Women:

– Gender inequality runs very deep in our society. Thus, we should think together on how to reduce it. We should help our population realize what gender equality is. Domestic violence is the result of husband and wife holding unequal positions in the household. Governmental response to this problem and development of a corresponding judicial mechanism to tackle issues in this field is very important.
Regardless of the location where gender inequality takes place or whether it occurs in ethnically Azerbaijani or Georgian households, whether it is the husband or a group of relatives who kill women, in all cases we have the same type of crime. Therefore, a society that knows about the occurrence of regular cases of violence against women but does not think it necessary to interfere in other families’ business (in the case of Azerbaijanis, there may be other factors influencing this) is just as guilty of this crime as a group of people who see a woman getting abused in the street but do nothing about it. In all cases, the reason for this silence lies in stereotypical thinking, according to which a woman is a powerless, dependent, lesser being, while a man has the right to control her morally, set behavior standards for her and punish her if she doesn’t behave as she is told.
A woman is of course an individual equal to a man, with her own opinions and outlook on life and she must have the opportunity and freedom to live the way she wants. No one should dictate to her what is right or wrong; responsibility for this is hers and hers alone. The solution is about equality, but this is a very long-term perspective. While for short-term solutions the intervention of law enforcement is necessary. Accordingly, laws regarding domestic violence should be adequate and prevention should occur in a timely fashion, such as the issuing of restraining orders and offering victims protection.

Print
Other Stories
Georgian businesswomen sisters sentenced to 4 years in prison
Legal proceedings on the so-called Center Point case have ended.
 Georgian priest charged with conspiracy to murder senior cleric
Prosecutors in Georgia have charged a high-ranking priest with conspiracy to murder after he was found to have attempted to fly out to visit the country’s religious leader
Patriarch’s deacon detained on charges of preparing assassination
Georgian Prosecutor’s Office detained deacon Giorgi Mamaladze on charges of preparing an assassination.
 Brother of famous Georgian actor found dead
A young man’s body was found in the village of Tsavkisi, 10 kilometers from the capital, yesterday.
Georgian man killed in Las Vegas was Ex-President Shevardnadze’s security team member
The man killed in a weekend shooting at a Starbucks coffee shop in Las Vegas was a naturalized U.S. citizen from the country of Georgia
Georgian woman accused of murdering her husband and child sentenced to life imprisonment
Magda Papidze, accused of murdering her husband and child, was sentenced to life imprisonment.
Seeking Closure?
Seeking Closure?
The Prosecutor’s Office stopped the investigation of the Erosi Kitsmarishvili case.
Law enforcers detain activists supporting LGBT society
May 17 marks International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia.
Five people detained over illegal possession of secret video footage reflecting private life
The Chief Prosecutor’s Office of Georgia has arrested five former officials over the fact of obtaining and keeping secret video footage
Another video showing private life released on the internet
Another video depicting private life of an individual was spread via Internet.
Noise to become punishable in Georgia
The Parliament's human rights committee approved the bill, according to which, noise becomes punishable in Georgia.
“Aleksi Petriashvili was threatened recently” - Georgia’s Free Democrats party leader wounded
One of the leaders of Free Democrats party, Aleksi Petriashvili was attacked and shot in the legs today.
Is Limited Liability Always “Limited”?
BY TAMARA TKESHELASHVILI AND MARIAM ANTIA, lawyers at Mgaloblishvili Kipiani Dzidziguri (MKD) law firm
National Probation Agency introduces house arrest
House arrest, a punitive measure representing an alternative to common imprisonment, has been implemented in Georgia in accordance with the new Justice Code.
Davit Dvali and Revaz Sakevarishvili appointed as temporary managers of Rustavi 2
Davit Dvali and Revaz Sakevarishvili were appointed as temporary managers of broadcasting company Rustavi
Tbilisi City Court satisfies Kibar Khalvashi’s request on handing over Rustavi 2 shares back
Tbilisi City Court has announced a verdict on the Rustavi 2 case. Under the decision of Judge Tamaz Urtmelidze, one
Justice Ministry launches procedures in order to deprive Mikheil Saakashvili of Georgian citizenship
As Georgia’s Justice Minister Tea Tsulukiani has declared
Will the Hague Revisit the Russian-Georgian War?
According to The International Criminal Court, The Hague’s renewed interest in the 2008 war between Georgia and Russia
Constitutional Court partly considers Gigi Ugulava’s complaint
The Constitutional Court has partly considered former Tbilisi Mayor Gigi Ugulava’s complaint.
Levan Gvazava's case – armed attack or attempted suicide?
Last week, a tragedy occurred at the territory of Okrokana, not far from Tbilisi – former Deputy Interior Minister Levan Gvazava
A Verdict in the Zurab Zhvania CaseA Verdict in the Zurab Zhvania Case
Was Georgia’s former prime minister killed by a carbon monoxide leak caused by an improperly installed gas heater
One of Zurab Zhvania’s bodyguards released from the courtroom and another stays in prison till December 24
The jury has issued a recommendation of softening the punishment for Zurab Zhvania’s security service employees
Greece's VIP inmate - What profit does the Georgian mafia try to make from the Greek crisis?
Georgian organized crime is once again a topic of foreign media attention. Before the referendum in Greece took place, the Italian media
New Beginnings
New Beginnings
Nepotism and unskillfulness – in order to tackle these two major problems, the government has recently announced a public service
The “Unsolved” Case - The Fate of Antonio Russo
If published in the West, Russo’s footage would have been disastrous for Russia. The journalist wanted
PHOTO OF THE DAY
Other Stories
The touching social ad released by the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Georgia received huge feedback not only in Georgia but also abroad.
After the verdict was announced, the ex-mayor of Tbilisi Gigi Ugulava entered the city court.
Former Tbilisi mayor Gigi Ugulava was sentenced to 9 years of imprisonment for embezzlement in the Tbilservice
Former Mayor of Tbilisi Gigi Ugulava has been released from prison.
The Ministry of Internal Affairs has posted a video depicting the incident involving MP Giorgi Karbelashvili.
MP Giorgi Karbelashvili has spent a few hours at a police station. According to Rustavi 2 TV, an incident took place in the village
Ministry of Internal Affairs of Georgia have held a presentation of a new ad showcasing the work of the agency
On the 8th of May, a man armed with an automatic weapon, tried to break into a currency exchange booth located near Didube subway station in Tbilisi
The Ministry of Internal Affairs has officially confirmed the detention of Shalva Abuladze, the prime suspect in two police officers’ murder.
Zurab Japaridze, a National Movement leader, presented video footage at today’s press conference that depicts a conversation between a citizen and police officers.
GEL Exchange
USD
1
USD
2.4076
EUR
1
EUR
2.6927
GBP
1
GBP
3.1215
RUB
100
RUB
4.2663